Adam’s Rib (1949)

George Cukor directs Spencer Tracy, Katharine Hepburn and Judy Holliday in this romantic comedy where husband and wife lawyers find themselves at opposing ends of a high profile attempted murder trial.

Didn’t grab me quite as firmly as other Hepburn & Tracy pairings. It is cute, they’re still great together, but I had issues. I know it’s a comedy but I struggled with the court case not being taken more seriously. I couldn’t fathom what the point scoring proved to the final verdict. And David Wayne’s predatory neighbour is annoying as fuck. Spencer Tracy should have run him and his piano out on a rail the first time he knocked around. Co-written by Ruth Gordon of Harold & Maude fame.

6

Perfect Double Bill: Born Yesterday (1950)

I write regular features about live comedy for British Comedy Guide here https://www.comedy.co.uk/people/bobby_carroll/features/ and my own Substack https://substack.com/@edinburghlaughterbulletin

Young Frankenstein (1974)

Mel Brooks directs Gene Wilder, Peter Boyle and Teri Garr in this spoof of the 1930’s Universal monster series.

Young Frankenstein is a strange one. If it catches me in the right mood then it is very funny. Yet more often than not, at least until the madcap final stretch, I just find myself admiring the loving forgery. The visual lifts and replication of the gothic originals are bang on. It also bizarrely reminds me of childhood Christmases. This always seemed to be scheduled on TV well past my bedtime on Christmas Eve, Boxing Day or New Year’s Eve. So watching even the first 10 minutes of Young Frankenstein at a cousin’s house or a party meant a taboo was being broken. These days I just enjoy watching peak Madeline Kahn or Teri Garr. They’re enough to raise the dead.

7

Perfect Double Bill: Blazing Saddles (1974)

Movies Of The Week: The Music Box (1932) / Busy Bodies (1933)

James Parrott and Lloyd French direct Stan Laurel, Oliver Hardy, Billy Gilbert, Charlie Hall, Tiny Sandford and Dick Gilbert in these slapstick shorts where Stan and Ollie cause chaos trying to complete jobs.

I love Laurel & Hardy. Here’s the famous one where they have to push a piano up some steep stairs. And another with some of their tricksiest visual gags (a car is sawn in half, Ollie gets sucked through a pipe). Whatever violence they commit on each other, and the wider world around them, it is their chemistry that always wins the day. The comedy equivalent of a nice hot bath. Or a glass of milk and dark chocolate digestives. Or eating salt and vinegar crisps on your parents’ sofa.

10/9

You can follow me on Letterboxd here https://letterboxd.com/BobbyCarroll

Nosferatu (2024)

Robert Eggers directs Lily-Rose Depp, Nicholas Hoult and Bill Skarsgård in this period gothic horror remake of the bootleg Dracula adaptation.

Dankly lush! Every frame a visual masterpiece. The dread is constant, each short scene building to a nasty crescendo yet never releasing the tension. Robin Carolan’s scratchy impatient score does tremendous work matching the relentless pace of the first hour. It is also surprisingly erotic with Lily-Rose Depp nailing her possessions and near pornographic convulsions. Sideburned cuck to hell, Nicholas Hoult is having a great year. Lacking the kitchen sink camp of Francis Ford Coppola’s Dracula and the stage bound creak of Bela Lugosi’s oldest version I’m going to bet the house and say this is not just the best take on Nosferatu but also the finest big screen Bram Stoker adaptation. Eggers previous endeavours have always felt a little overly composed… precious show-off projects… This is a living breathing, fully entertaining classic horror flick in its own right. His first movie where the storytelling and perverse emotion tower over the artistic intent. A fascinating talent comes of age.

9

Perfect Double Bill: Bram Stoker’s Dracula (1992)

The Order (2024)

Justin Kurzel directs Jude Law, Nicholas Hoult and Tye Sheridan in this crime thriller based on the true story of a FBI agent chasing a white supremacist gang that plans to overthrow the U.S. government.

Very much the same Eighties true story as Joe Eszterhas exploited back in the day as Betrayed. Only here the vibe is more aiming for a pared down Heat or Point Break than a Neo-Nazi Jagged Edge. Kurzel tries to avoid too much hand wringing judgment over the far-right splinter group. There is no cartoon villainy here. They are evil but undemonised and in a way that makes their existence even more terrifying. The matter of fact brutality holds the flick in good stead whether you consume it as a testosterone fulled drama or a high minded B-Movie thriller. Was the unpopulated emptiness of the streets where the action thunders about in a choice or a budgetary necessity? I had no idea The Order even existed until a week before it’s limited cinema release and it ended up being one of my multiplex going highlights of 2024. Haunting and pulse raising in equal measure.

8

Perfect Double Bill: The Believer (2001)

I write regular features about live comedy for British Comedy Guide here https://www.comedy.co.uk/people/bobby_carroll/features/ and my own Substack https://substack.com/@edinburghlaughterbulletin

Wicked: Part One (2024)

Jon M. Chu directs Cynthia Erivo, Ariana Grande and Jeff Goldblum in this musical fantasy prequel where the future Wicked Witch Of The West and Glinda The Good become university roommates in the land of Oz.

Ariana Grande’s delightfully off key performance made this for me. Camp, self absorbed and knowingly unaware she really injects fun into every scene she’s in. What if Jim Carrey played an all singing, all dancing, all pink wearing Mean Girl? Impressive production design and a fealty to cinematic Ozs of past eras meant Wicked really hit the spot.

7

Perfect Double Bill: Wicked: For Good (2025)

Queer (2024)

Luca Guadagnino directs Daniel Craig, Drew Starkey and Jason Schwartzman in this period romantic drama based on William S. Burroughs novel set in South America.

You couldn’t imagine a Roger Moore flick with this much simulated semen. Hmmm… Craig stretches his acting muscles here. The sex scenes are strong with the former Bond grabbing crack and nuzzling schlong. There are ebbs at surrealism. I liked the miniature FX work. We all lust for youth, infatuated with what we have lost to time. There is beauty and ugliness in obsession. As an entertainment it is quite boring and one note. Lingering far too long on its points and beats, making them almost redundant. Frustrating, eventually exhausting.

5

Perfect Double Bill: Drugstore Cowboy (1989)

You can follow me on Letterboxd here https://letterboxd.com/BobbyCarroll

What’s Up Doc? (1972)

Peter Bogdanovich directs Barbra Streisand, Ryan O’Neal and Madeline Kahn in this screwball comedy where four guests in a San Francisco hotel have the same identical plaid travelling bag and chaos ensues as they get mixed-up, stolen then chased.

I’m not a big fan of either lead but Madeline Kahn is superb as the nag. Just stay with her O’Neal… she’s worth the henpecking. This is often framed as some daring revival of a long lost genre but it is hard to ignore It’s A Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad World happened less than a decade previously!? This has more sparkle, that had more gags. Both feel corny now.

6

Perfect Double Bill: Love Story (1970)

Star Wars: Episode I – The Phantom Menace (1999) / Star Wars: Episode II – Attack Of The Clones (2002)

George Lucas directs Liam Neeson, Ewan McGregor, Natalie Portman, Hayden Christensen, Samuel L. Jackson and Ian McDiarmid in these prequels to the blockbuster space adventure trilogy where we meet young Anakin Skywalker before he becomes Darth Vader.

There’s nothing new that can be written about the shockingly abrasive prequel episodes that almost derailed Star Wars for the generation that grew up with it. I’m not going to lay too heavily into child performances, or icky wooden romances, or even Jar-Jar Binks. Jar-Jar isn’t my cup of tea but he belongs in a family movie. Maybe not a family movie about trade embargoes, taxation, fascism and forbidden lust for teens. The Padme / Anakin crush is now far more awkward and disturbing than a slightly racist CGI comedy sidekick. Maybe the future Sith Lord is using his underage powers to influence the twenty-something regal honey. Maybe Jar-Jar is also a Sith. Now there’s a kickback online fan theory that actually makes his weird presence quite engaging in retrospect.

The epic pod race is exciting. Iconic new villain Darth Maul got a good duel and a memorable “death”. John William’s Duel Of The Fates orchestral music is premium. All the Jedis turning up to fight droids in the gladiator arena has its moments. Neeson is well cast in the first one, McGregor comes into his own in Clones. Gifted with his own little detective quest that allows him room to breathe. I always want to rehabilitate these idiosyncratic entries but I confess I am clutching at Star Straws. Stay off those Death Sticks kids if you think Batman V Superman or Prometheus are anywhere near as iffy. It is hard to love two things this continually disappointing and wholly inexplicable.

When compared to what came before these two are almost irredeemable. The unreliable green screen FX works is leant into too foolishly. Every moment of excitement is hobbled by glaring fakery. A CGI stunt person who contorts like a polygon marionette. A constant pixel ugliness. Someone needed to be hired who could say “No” to George Lucas. “No” to using tech that wasn’t up to task. “No” to his screenwriting choices. “No” to his dreck dialogue. “No” to his humour. “No” to the yippees inserted in in post. If that producer existed we would have tighter, more action orientated movies, ones where the limitations might have created beauty and elegance. Instead we have four and half hours where you really have to sift through muck to find entertainment, to find that old magic. Garish enigmas yet still Star Wars.

5/5

I write regular features about live comedy for British Comedy Guide here https://www.comedy.co.uk/people/bobby_carroll/features/ and my own Substack https://substack.com/@edinburghlaughterbulletin

Devil In The Flesh (1998)

Steve Cohen directs Rose McGowan, Alex McArthur and Peg Shirley in this erotic thriller where a bad seed teen lands in a new town ready to seduce a teacher, battle her evangelical grandmother and kill anyone else in her way.

The Crush or Poison Ivy but done real cheap and on random settings. Rose McGowan overcomes a very bland obsession interest (he really isn’t worth it) and the fact the producers literally create a character just to inject some occasional nudity into the proceedings. No nudity necessary as McGowan’s tight revealing fits and unhinged behaviour are spicy enough. Terrible film almost saved by its star = The Rose McGowan Story.

4

Perfect Double Bill: Lewis and Clark and George (1997)